While there are still several more sequels yet to emerge at the box office (Ocean’s 13, The Bourne Ultimatum, Fantastic Four 2, Harry Potter 5, Rush Hour 3, Saw 4), the 3 earliest (and perhaps most major) players in the box office game have already made their mark – Spider-Man 3, Shrek the Third, and Pirates of the Caribbean: At World’s End. Unsurprisingly, they were the top 3 earners over the Memorial Day Holiday Weekend. Spider-Man 3 broke the opening weekend record, pulling in $151 million in its first week. Shrek the Third broke the animated weekend record, pulling in $121 million two weeks after Spider-Man 3 opened and then Pirates 3 did $142 million over the holiday weekend, enough for first place in the race, but not enough to break Spider-Man 3’s recent record.
Alli and I have managed to make it to all three sequels and I’ve found each to not quite meet my expectations. The critics have railed against all of them for the most part, and with good reason. None of them has yet captured the brilliance of the original movies in the series. To most, the second in the series was a letdown. While the Pirates and Shrek franchises have managed to bounce back a little from their 2nd offerings, I thought none of the movies lived up to the expectations or the hype that their PR machines had generated for them this spring.
Spider-Man 3
Let me get this out of the way up front – I cannot stand Kirsten Dunst. I’ve never liked her in the Spider-Man movies and I always thought her chemistry with Tobey Maguire stank. She has nearly ruined some great movies (Eternal Sunshine of the Spotless Mind) and hasn’t done a single good thing since Interview with the Vampire (save the aberration Bring It On, which I attribute to Gabrielle Union and Eliza Dushku). I just wanted to make sure that my preliminary bias is out there before I go off on this movie.
Obviously, I hated Dunst as Mary Jane. I mean I really couldn’t stand her. I really wanted Peter Parker to dump MJ halfway through the movie and hook up with Gwen Stacy for good. Bryce Dallas Howard acted CIRCLES around Dunst.
What bothered me most about Spider-Man 3 was that it was just a mess. I understand the multiple villains and their representation of the themes of revenge and redemption, but I just felt that Sandman was really distracting. I thought Thomas Haden Church was downright awful as Flint Marko. He brought virtually NOTHING to the character except gross chapped lips that looked more collagen-filled than Lisa Rinna.
I thought that the kid from That 70’s Show was pretty good and held his own playing – a darker version of Eric Forman. I half expected during the random dance scene that Fez and Jackie would show up a bust out some Travolta moves from Saturday Night Fever. But alas – it remained just a random dance scene in the middle of a comic book movie.
Overall, I didn’t like it nearly as much as I wanted to, but I still thought it was better than Spider-Man 2. They certainly spent a lot on effects, but as cool as it is seeing Spider-Man swinging through the city chasing bad guys, it got a little old. I’m not a comic guy, so I can understand how people might not understand that, but I just wanted a simpler, more straight-forward story.
Shrek the Third
I had very high hopes for the next movie on the list – Shrek the Third. The first Shrek movie is perhaps my favorite animated movie of the modern era. It was so creative and funny that it was difficult not to love it. You can understand why Mssrs. Spielberg, Katzenberg, and Geffen turned it into a franchise for Dreamworks. HELLO MERCHANDISING!
Shrek 2 was a bit of a disappointment to me, but as I watched it more, the funnier it got. On first watch, I definitely liked Shrek the Third more than Shrek 2. I thought that it had perhaps the best plot out of all three of the movies and I really liked how they tried to incorporate some new talent into the fold. They found success in Shrek 2 with Antonio Banderas as Puss in Boots and so they brought in stalwarts like Eric Idle to voice the character of Merlin. They also made brilliant choices for the spoiled princesses, using Amy Poehler, Amy Sedaris, Maya Rudolph, and Cheri Oteri (a grossly underused comedic talent). Unfortunately, their little nuggets of comedy were overshadowed by the complete overuse of Rupert Everett. Look, Rupe, I loved you in My Best Friend’s Wedding, but your Charming was just downright annoying and you got WAY too much screen time. You even drew time away from the Shrek/Donkey/Puss dynamic that had so much potential.
While I really enjoyed the movie, the more I thought about it, the more I wanted from it. Hopefully they’ll either retire the franchise or get some extremely good writers for the next one.
Pirates of the Caribbean: At World’s End
Last Friday, Alli and I braved the holiday weekend and went to see the third installment of Disney’s effects-laden popcorn flicks based on a pretty lame ride. Let’s face it, after Pirates of the Caribbean: Dead Man’s Chest, moviegoers were really left with no choice but to see the third one.
Clocking in at just under 3 hours, At World’s End is LONG. And not in a good way. I thought it was entertaining, but it just felt like Disney shoved 30 writers into a room, gave them some pizza and beer and said, “Write Pirates 3. Oh yeah, and make sure you give Keith Richards a part.”
It just felt really convoluted and while the ending was pretty satisfying, I didn’t like everything that led up to it. Johnny Depp’s Jack Sparrow is a scene chewer, but he is mysteriously absent for the first 45-50 minutes of the movie. That didn’t make sense to me, although the scene in which he returns is very funny and clever. It was one of my favorite parts of the movie.
Keira Knightly was leaned on a lot more heavily in this movie, but unfortunately she had to act opposite Geoffrey Rush’s Captain Barbossa for most of the movie, which was a difficult task – Barbossa was pretty awesome.
I just felt that if Disney was going to force me into seeing the third one by leaving me hanging like they did at the end of the second movie, they could have done it without a giant sea witch who turns into a bunch of crabs. That’s right. You read that correctly.
Overall, I was least disappointed by Shrek the Third thus far in the movie season. I haven’t been wowed yet, but there’s still a lot of summer left.
Recent Comments